Bugster
Resources•Software Testing••10 min read

7 Best Practices for Writing Maintainable Test Scripts

7 Best Practices for Writing Maintainable Test Scripts

7 Best Practices for Writing Maintainable Test Scripts

Maintaining test scripts is critical for saving time, reducing costs, and ensuring software quality. Did you know 70% of test scripts become obsolete within three months without updates? Or that companies spend 50-80% of test automation efforts on maintenance? This guide covers 7 practical strategies to keep your tests reliable and efficient:

  • Build Modular Test Components: Create reusable, single-purpose blocks for easier updates.
  • Add Smart Element Detection: Use stable selectors and AI tools to fix broken elements.
  • Separate Test Data from Scripts: Store data externally for flexibility and faster updates.
  • Use Version Control Effectively: Track changes and collaborate seamlessly.
  • Automate Test Updates: Leverage AI and self-healing frameworks to keep tests in sync.
  • Speed Up Test Runs in CI/CD: Run tests in parallel and focus on high-priority issues.
  • Focus Testing on High-Risk Areas: Prioritize critical features and remove flaky tests.

These practices help teams cut maintenance time, detect bugs early, and improve test reliability. Let’s dive into each one to see how they work.

Ways to Reduce Test-Automation Maintenance Efforts

1. Build Modular Test Components

Breaking test scripts into smaller, reusable parts makes them easier to maintain over time. A great example of this comes from Autodesk's QA team in 2023. They revamped their AutoCAD test suite by creating modular components for common CAD tasks. The result? A 45% reduction in test maintenance time and a 30% boost in test coverage (Source: Autodesk Engineering Blog, 2024).

Create Reusable Test Blocks

Focus on making each block handle just one specific task (following the Single Responsibility Principle). For instance, instead of duplicating login code across multiple tests, create a single, parameterized function like this:

def login(username, password):
    """Logs in with the provided credentials"""
    driver.get("https://example.com/login")
    driver.find_element_by_id("username").send_keys(username)
    driver.find_element_by_id("password").send_keys(password)
    driver.find_element_by_id("login-button").click()
    return "Welcome" in driver.title

This approach keeps your code clean and easy to update when changes occur.

Organize Shared Function Libraries

Group your reusable components into libraries based on their purpose. This keeps everything organized and ensures consistency across your tests. Here’s an example setup:

# ui_interactions.py
def click_element(locator):
    """Clicks on a specified element"""
    # Implementation

# data_handling.py
def generate_random_email():
    """Creates a random email address for testing purposes"""
    # Implementation

# assertions.py
def assert_element_visible(locator, timeout=10):
    """Checks if an element is visible within a given timeout"""
    # Implementation

By centralizing these functions, you make updates easier and avoid duplicating work.

Leverage AI for Better Test Design

AI tools like Bugster's Flow-Based Test Agent can take modular testing to the next level. These tools analyze your scripts, identify repetitive patterns, and suggest ways to improve structure. According to recent stats, 81% of software teams now incorporate AI into their testing workflows [4].

For example, if a UI update breaks a test component, Bugster's AI can suggest fixes or even create new components that work with the updated interface. This not only saves time but also ensures your tests stay relevant and effective.

2. Add Smart Element Detection

Building your tests with modular components is a great start, but ensuring they remain reliable requires smart element detection. QA teams often struggle with tests breaking due to fragile element selectors, so having a solid detection strategy is crucial.

Choose Stronger Element Selectors

Avoid using brittle CSS selectors. Instead, opt for stable attributes like this:

#main-content > div:nth-child(2) > button

should become:

[data-testid='submit-button']

This approach can reduce maintenance efforts by 60-65%, as reported by leading enterprise teams. Here's what they focus on:

  • Using unique data attributes for key test elements
  • Leveraging semantic HTML with clear roles
  • Applying text patterns for static content
  • Preferring relative selectors over absolute paths

Use AI to Fix Broken Selectors

AI-powered tools can handle UI changes automatically, saving time and effort. These tools repair broken selectors by analyzing the app’s structure and historical data. They rely on:

  • Examining the context of surrounding elements
  • Using fallback selector hierarchies
  • Applying visual recognition to identify elements

This method directly supports the 40% testing cost reduction mentioned earlier.

Incorporate Image-Based Checks

Adding visual verification to your tests can catch issues that element-based methods often miss. In fact, image-based testing identifies 35% more visual bugs [4].

Use this technique for checking graphics, branding, cross-browser compatibility, and dynamic content. It works well alongside other detection methods and strengthens the reliability of your tests. This visual layer ties in perfectly with the data separation strategies discussed later.

3. Separate Test Data from Scripts

Building on modular components and effective element detection, keeping test data separate from scripts helps your testing process adapt to new scenarios. This approach allows scripts to be reused across different scenarios and cuts down maintenance time by as much as 50-80% [2].

Store Test Data Externally

Pick a storage format that suits the complexity of your data. For instance, JSON and YAML work well with hierarchical data, while flat files like CSV are better for simpler setups. Here’s an example in Python using JSON for external test data:

# test_data.json
{
  "login_scenarios": [
    {
      "username": "admin_user",
      "password": "secure123",
      "expected": "dashboard"
    }
  ]
}

# test_login.py
import json

def load_test_data():
    with open('test_data.json') as f:
        return json.load(f)

def test_login():
    data = load_test_data()['login_scenarios'][0]
    result = perform_login(data['username'], data['password'])
    assert result == data['expected']

With this setup, you only need to update the data file when changes are required - no need to touch the code.

Run Tests with Multiple Data Sets

Data-driven testing becomes easier when you parameterize test flows. For example, use CSV files for login scenarios, JSON for API payloads, and separate files for environment configurations.

Update Test Data Using AI

AI-powered testing tools can simplify test data management by:

  • Creating realistic data that mimics actual application usage
  • Identifying outdated scenarios that need revision
  • Recommending data combinations for better coverage
  • Keeping test data synchronized across environments

4. Use Version Control Effectively

Separating test data helps streamline processes, but version control takes it a step further by keeping everything organized and easy to track. Teams that adopt version control for test scripts report 35% fewer regression bugs [1].

Set Up Test Script Branches

Adopt a branching strategy that allows for parallel development:

  • Feature branches: Start new features from a central development branch.
  • Release branches: Create branches specific to each version's test suite.
  • Hotfix branches: Use these for urgent production fixes.

Keep the main branch stable and ready for production. Use feature branches for ongoing development, and merge changes into the main branch only after peer reviews and validation.

Monitor and Revert Changes

Use descriptive commit messages to document the intent behind changes. Here's an example:

Add user authentication test suite
- Implement tests for login, logout, and password reset
- Cover edge cases for invalid credentials
- Set up test data fixtures for various user roles
Relates to #123

When problems occur, Git tools can help maintain stability:

  • git revert: Undo changes while keeping the history intact.
  • git checkout: Restore specific files to earlier versions.
  • Tagged releases: Use tags like git tag v1.0.0 for clear versioning.

Connect with Build Pipelines

Link version control to CI/CD pipelines to automate test execution. For instance, this GitHub Actions workflow runs tests whenever code changes are pushed or a pull request is made:

name: Test Automation
on:
  push:
    branches: [ main, develop ]
  pull_request:
    branches: [ main ]

jobs:
  test:
    runs-on: ubuntu-latest
    steps:
      - uses: actions/checkout@v3
      - name: Run Test Suite
        run: |
          npm install
          npm run test
      - name: Store Test Results
        uses: actions/upload-artifact@v3
        with:
          name: test-results
          path: test-results/

Organizations using this setup report a 92% boost in team collaboration [5]. This directly supports the goal of minimizing technical debt and improving efficiency.

sbb-itb-b77241c

5. Automate Test Updates

Keeping your tests in sync with application changes is crucial, especially with the high obsolescence rate of 70%. While version control helps track test history, automation ensures your tests stay relevant as your application evolves.

Enable Auto-Fixing Tests

Modern testing frameworks now offer self-healing features that adjust to changes in the user interface automatically. Take Bugster's AI-powered system as an example:

  • It creates a baseline for UI and functionality.
  • Detects changes in real time.
  • Updates test scripts automatically.
  • Validates the modified tests.

For instance, if a button's ID changes from 'submit-btn' to 'submit-button', Bugster updates all related tests without requiring manual effort [2].

Check Impact of Code Changes

Predicting how code changes affect tests can save time and reduce errors. Tools like Microsoft's CODEBEAT achieve this with 90% accuracy by combining static analysis and machine learning [3].

Here’s how it works:

  • Static code analysis maps tests to specific code sections.
  • Machine learning identifies which tests might be impacted.
  • Dependency graphs trace the paths of these impacts.
  • Tests are scheduled based on priority.

This workflow ensures that the most critical tests are addressed first, streamlining the process.

Fix Unstable Tests Automatically

Flaky tests can waste 20-50% of CI/CD execution time, as shown by Google's data [6]. Google's Flaky Test Handler tackles this issue effectively, cutting flaky test failures by 80% in their CI pipeline [6].

A combination of strategies powers this system:

  • Detection tools flag unstable tests early.
  • Root cause analysis identifies why tests fail.
  • Self-healing frameworks repair broken locators.
  • Retry mechanisms manage temporary issues.

6. Speed Up Test Runs in CI/CD

Slow tests can hold up releases and drive up maintenance costs. Building on the version control practices from Section 4, speeding up test runs helps validate code changes more efficiently.

Run Tests in Parallel

Using modular test components (as discussed in Section 1) allows you to run tests in parallel by minimizing dependencies. Here's an example configuration:

# Example setup for running tests on 4 nodes
jobs:
  test:
    parallelism: 4
    steps: [checkout, installation, test run]

This setup splits the workload, reducing overall test execution time.

Reduce Test Debugging Time

Machine learning tools can analyze logs to streamline debugging. They can:

  • Detect anomalies in test logs automatically.
  • Identify patterns tied to common failures.
  • Send real-time alerts for critical issues.

These features make it easier to pinpoint and resolve problems quickly.

Test Across Browsers and Devices

Cross-browser testing ensures your application works seamlessly across platforms. Building on the element detection methods from Section 2, cloud-based tools can simplify multi-platform testing. Here's a sample configuration:

jobs:
  test:
    docker:
      - image: circleci/node:14
    steps:
      - checkout
      - run:
          name: "Cross-browser tests"
          command: |
            npm install
            npm run test:browserstack

Running tests in the cloud keeps your CI/CD pipeline fast while ensuring compatibility across different browsers and devices.

7. Focus Testing on High-Risk Areas

Fast CI/CD pipelines are great for speeding up validation, but focusing your testing efforts on high-risk areas ensures you're spending time where it matters most. According to a study by Tricentis, companies using risk-based testing see software releases hit the market 44% faster [8].

Test Critical Features First

Make sure your testing aligns with business priorities. Tools like Testim.io use machine learning to analyze test execution history and code changes, helping you automatically identify and prioritize high-risk areas [2]. When assessing feature importance, think about factors like:

Risk Factor Example Criteria
User Impact Core business operations
Revenue Impact Payment processing flows
Security Risk Authentication systems

Parasoft takes this a step further by dynamically adjusting test coverage based on code changes and associated risks.

Remove Unreliable Tests

If a test keeps giving inconsistent results, it’s time to either refactor it with stronger selectors or replace it with API-level tests. These are less prone to UI-related issues and help maintain stability.

Allocate Maintenance Resources Strategically

Eggplant Digital Automation Intelligence uses a model-based digital twin of your application to guide resource allocation with AI [7]. Here’s how it helps:

  • Resource Optimization: Analyze defect trends and use production data to direct resources where they’re needed most. Focus on areas that align with real user behavior.
  • Predictive Analytics: Use machine learning to study historical test data and predict potential issues. This allows you to address problems before they arise.

This targeted, risk-aware approach keeps your testing efforts efficient and aligned with your core maintenance goals, avoiding wasted time on low-priority tests.

Keys to Long-Term Test Maintenance

Maintaining test automation over time demands careful tool selection and well-thought-out processes. With AI now playing a role in over 80% of testing workflows [4], teams are better equipped to tackle outdated scripts head-on.

Here’s how these practices work together to improve outcomes:

  • Modular components: Simplify maintenance by following consistent patterns.
  • Smart element detection: Keeps tests stable even when the UI changes.
  • Data separation: Makes updates easier and faster.
  • Version control: Encourages seamless collaboration among team members.
  • AI-powered automation: Cuts down on repetitive manual tasks.
  • Efficient CI/CD pipelines: Quickly validate changes and spot issues.
  • Risk-based testing: Focuses resources where they matter most.

The key is blending technical precision (like modular design and smart detection) with strong processes (such as version control and CI/CD). Companies that embrace this combined approach often see major gains in test reliability and easier maintenance.

FAQs

What design patterns have you used in automation frameworks?

Design patterns in test automation help keep frameworks organized and easier to maintain. The Page Object Model (POM) is a widely used approach, with 87% of organizations using test automation reporting better software quality [1].

These patterns expand on the modular approach discussed earlier by introducing more structure to test organization. Here’s a quick look at some key design patterns and their benefits:

Pattern Benefit
Page Object Model Centralizes updates, reducing maintenance efforts
Factory Pattern Makes cross-browser testing simpler
Singleton Pattern Keeps the test environment consistent
Fluent Page Object Improves code readability and clarity

The Fluent Page Object pattern, in particular, enhances code readability while still retaining the maintenance advantages of POM.

AutomationCI/CDTesting